---

Community Management With AI

TL;DR

• AI can triage questions, flag toxicity, and suggest responses. It can't build belonging or read emotional nuance.
• Use AI for scale: routing, spam, obvious answers. Reserve humans for empathy, escalation, and relationship.
• The goal is a healthier community, not a more automated one. Optimize for trust, not efficiency.

Communities scale. Moderation doesn't. Or didn't — until AI. Now you can automate triage, detect spam, and even draft replies. But communities thrive on feeling heard. A bot can't do that. Your job: use AI where it helps, stay human where it matters.

What AI Can Handle

Triage and routing:

• "Is this a bug, a feature request, or a how-to question?" AI can classify. Route to the right channel or person.
• Saves time. Reduces "where do I post this?" friction.

Spam and toxicity detection:

• Obvious spam, hate speech, clear violations — AI can flag. Human reviews for edge cases.
• Don't fully automate bans. False positives burn trust.

First-response drafts:

• "Thanks for your question. Here's a link to the docs that might help." AI can draft. You or a human approves.
• For complex or emotional threads, skip the draft. Respond personally.

FAQ and common answers:

• "How do I reset my password?" AI can pull from docs and suggest a reply. Fine for repetitive stuff.
• When someone is frustrated or confused, a canned response feels like a brush-off. Personalize.

What AI Can't Do

Empathy:

• "I've been stuck on this for 3 days." AI might suggest a link. A human might say "that's frustrating — let's figure it out." Big difference.
• Community = belonging. Belonging needs humans.

Context and history:

• "This user has had 5 failed attempts. They're probably frustrated." AI might not connect the dots. You can.
• Use context. Don't treat every message as isolated.

Judgment on edge cases:

• Is this criticism constructive or toxic? Is this person confused or trolling? AI will get some wrong.
• When in doubt, human review. When it's sensitive, human only.

Building relationships:

• The best community members are the ones who feel known. "Hey, saw you shipped that project — congrats!" AI can't do that authentically.
• You can. Do it.

The Hybrid Model

• Tier 1: AI triages, suggests, or auto-responds for obvious cases. Human reviews a sample.
• Tier 2: Human responds, possibly using AI-drafted text as a starting point. Edits for tone and accuracy.
• Tier 3: Human only. Escalations, emotional support, ambiguous situations, VIPs.

Metrics That Matter

• Response time (AI can help)
• Resolution rate (AI + human)
• Community sentiment and retention (human-led culture)
• "Would you recommend this community?" — AI can't fix a toxic or indifferent culture. You can.

Do This Next

1. Map your community touchpoints — Which can be AI-assisted? Which must be human? Document it.
2. Run a week of AI-assisted triage — Use it for routing and drafting. Measure: Did resolution improve? Did anyone complain about feeling unheard?
3. Schedule "human time" — Block time to personally respond to a batch of threads. No AI. Compare the feedback.